How to Remove Press-On Nails Without Damaging Your Real Nails

Step 2: Soak Your Nails

“The best way to remove press-ons is to soak them in a small ceramic or glass bowl filled with acetone-based nail polish remover,” says Edwards. Soak until the glue breaks down and the nails become loose enough to effortlessly pull them off or until they fall off on their own. This method works for press-on nails that you have to glue on yourself and the ones that have the adhesive already on them.

To speed up the process, Edwards says you can also use an artificial nail remover kit. Whatever you choose, remember to be patient. If you yank off your press-ons before they’re ready, it could strip layers off your natural nails and damage them. We love the Olive & June Bye-Bye Press-Ons Removal System.

Step 3: Use a Soft Buffer

If you’re soaking your nails and notice that they’re still not easily coming off, Edwards recommends using a soft nail buffer to carefully remove them. “Never, ever pull up the false nails or file harshly,” she says.

Step 4: Apply a Nail Strengthener

It’s likely that after all that glue and acetone, your nails are in need of a little TLC, so be sure to follow up with a nail strengthener. We love the Essie Hard to Resist Nail Strengthener because it strengthens nails to their original resiliency in just three days.