6 Undupe-able Makeup Products — According to Reddit

Urban Decay Vice Lipstick in Amulet

The original poster of the thread, Rredditor 3mpty_spac3, offered up Urban Decay Vice Lipstick in Amulet — a metallic brick rose that’s ultra-pigmented and loaded with lip-nourishing ingredients like aloe vera, avocado oil and Illipe butter. It’s available in the Vice Liquid Lipstick formula, too, so you can rock it all day touch-up free if that’s more your style.

Gerard Cosmetics HydraMatte Lipstick in Invasion

Redditors gave Gerard Cosmetics HydraMatte Lipstick in Invasion the most upvotes. The gray-toned lipstick is bold yet neutral, and it never fails to earn Redditor mikiesaurus compliments with every wear. As for the formula — it’s matte without being drying, has a comfortable finish and lasts all day.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyeshadow in Buon Fresco

Another highly recommended un-dupeable shade was Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyeshadow in Buon Fresco — specifically in the Modern Renaissance palette (it’s rumored that the single shadow and palette shade are different). Redditor devieous credits the shade with opening them up to cool toned eyeshadow looks and another claims when used in the crease it “almost blends itself out” and offers a multidimensional effect. Pretty special if you ask us.

Cirque Colors Nail Polish in Cloud Nine

We’ve all bought things thanks to the lure of a good Instagram post — Redditor markrichtsspraytan included. Although they “rarely buy new makeup or nail polish,” they saw Cirque Colors Nail Polish in Cloud Nine and had to have it. The shimmery lavender polish is packed with multidimensional pigments that offer a sheer wash of color with one coat (hello jelly nails!) and an opaque finish with two or three.

Sugarpill Loose Eyeshadow in Lumi

This shade from Sugarpill is truly un-dupeable, an iridescent snow white hue with turquoise color shifts. The versatile loose powder format means you can use it as an eyeshadow, highlighter or even a lipstick topper. Redditor daniellerosenalouise says they’ve “never found a shadow that was a good dupe,” and TBH, neither have we.

Urban Decay Moondust Eyeshadow in Solstice

Suggested by the original poster and Reddit user SweetTeaBags, Urban Decay Moondust Eyeshadow is one of a kind. The metallic pink-red shade has green 3-D sparkles and a multi-dimensional shift that can’t be duplicated. As for wearability, Redditors suggest pairing the unique hue with a cool-toned brown shadow or wearing it on top of matte black to make the color really pop.