Colored Mascara Is An Easy Way To Spice Up Your Eye Look

Best colored mascara for brown eyes

Brown eyes can range from a light honey color to a deep, almost black hue. If your eyes are on the lighter side, reach for a deep blue mascara to help bring out the natural golden tones in your irises. We love the YSL Beauty Lash Clash Extreme Volume Mascara in Electric Blue, as it provides intense color payoff and wears for up to 24 hours without smudging. For those with deeper chocolatey brown eyes, we suggest opting for a rich purple mascara, like the L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Original Washable Bold Eye Mascara in Deep Violet.

Best colored mascara for blue eyes

Orange sits directly across from blue on the color wheel, which in theory, means that orange mascaras are the best to make icy blue eyes shine. That being said, tangerine lashes can feel a bit too intense for everyday wear. For a more versatile option, consider opting for a warmer-toned reddish or burgundy mascara. The L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Original Washable Bold Eye Mascara in Deep Burgundy is among our favorites for a noticeable but not overpowering pop of color.

Best colored mascara for green eyes

If you’ve been gifted with green eyes, consider yourself lucky—this eye color is not only gorgeous, but also quite rare (according to the Cleveland Clinic, only about 2% of people have emerald irises). Using a red or pink mascara can help accentuate the earthy tones in your eyes and make that special color pop. The burgundy mascara mentioned above is a great pick, but if you want something even more vibrant, try the Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara in Pink Air. The cotton candy-like hue is bold, bright, and unapologetically fun.

Best colored mascara for hazel eyes

Hazel eyes contain an assortment of hues, from luscious caramel browns to bright, grassy greens. While an array of hues can complement hazel eyes, we’re especially fond of the way green mascara can help draw attention to your eyes’ natural depth. Try a dark hunter green option, such as the L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Original Washable Bold Eye Mascara in Deep Green.

8 Colored Mascara Looks To Try

Colored mascara pops on its own, but if you want to take you a r look to the next level, keep scrolling—below, we’re sharing eight ways to wear your colorful mascara for a look that wows.

Shimmery lids and burgundy mascara

Burgundy mascara is perfect for nights out, as the deep, rich shade feels sultry without being over the top. To enhance your look, pair your wine-toned with a shimmery champagne or bronze eyeshadow (we love the Urban Decay 24/7 Moondust Eyeshadow Singles in Space Cowboy). The golden tones of the shadow will help accentuate the warm hue of your mascara for a cohesive (and unbelievably flattering) end result.

Earthy shadow and green lashes

You can wear colored mascara even if you’re someone who typically favors more neutral tones in your makeup. For a subtle yet striking look, try pairing a deep emerald green mascara with matte brown eyeshadow and bronzed cheeks. Eyeliner is optional, but if you use it, opt for a brown (rather than black) liner to keep your look feeling soft.

Cobalt statement eye

This one’s for those who favor a more-is-more approach to makeup. Start by swiping an electric blue shadow, such as the NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil in Blueberry Pop, onto your lids, blending the color up toward your crease. Then, swipe on a few coats of the L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Original Washable Eye Mascara in Cobalt Blue to lengthen, volumize, and tint your lashes. Because this blue mascara makeup look is so bold, we suggest keeping the rest of your makeup simple—a bit of highlighter and a swipe of clear lip gloss make for the perfect finishing touches.

Colorful bottom lashes

If you want to make a statement without committing to anything too bold, consider using a brown or black mascara on your upper lashes, then swiping a vibrant colored mascara on your lower lashes for a fun, two-toned effect.

Pink mascara

Baby pink lashes aren’t for the faint of heart, but if you’re willing to experiment with the pastel look, you’ll discover just how flattering (and fun!) it can be. Apply a few coats of the Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Mascara Makeup in Pink Air onto your upper and lower lashes for a pop of pink, or go all out by pairing your mascara with rosy lips, cheeks, and lids.

Rainbow lashes

If you’re feeling extra tenacious, you can try out rainbow lashes—though be advised, nailing this look is slightly more time-consuming than your typical mascara application. To create it, grab three or four of your favorite colored mascara and swipe them onto your lashes in sections, holding the applicator vertically instead of horizontally. You can achieve a rainbow effect by using pink mascara in your inner corners, burgundy and blue mascara for the central lashes, and green mascara at the outer corners. If that feels too complicated, try using a different color on each set of lashes (left upper and lower; right upper and lower) for a rainbow color-blocked effect.

Blue lashes and liner

Blue mascara can be subtle, or it can be graphic—this look definitely falls into the latter category. To create a similar look, draw on a graphic, dramatic wing with a bright blue eyeliner, such as the NYX Professional Makeup Vivid Brights Colored Liquid Eyeliner in Cobalt Crush. Once the liner sets, swipe a blue mascara, like the Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Mascara onto your upper and lower lashes for length, volume, and tons of look-at-me color.

Pink and green mascara

Pink and green are kind of like peanut butter and jelly: they just go together. For a playful (and party-ready) eye makeup look, apply a deep green mascara to your upper lashes and use a bright pink mascara to tint your lower lashes. You can rock the look as-is, but we think a generous swipe of glittery eyeshadow ties the unconventional look together perfectly.

Next Up: 12 Blue Mascaras for When You’re Craving a Pop of Color